Will Social Security Be There When You Retire?

By Michael Ruger, CFP®
Partner and Chief Investment Officer at Greenbush Financial Group

If you’ve looked at your Social Security statement recently, you may have noticed a troubling note: beginning in 2034, the system will no longer have enough funding to pay out full promised benefits. For many Americans, this raises a big question: Will Social Security even be there when I retire?

In this article, we’ll break down:

• How Social Security is currently funded and why it faces challenges

• What the 2034 date really means (hint: it’s not “bankruptcy”)

• Why Congress is likely to act before major benefit cuts happen

• Practical solutions that could shore up the system for future retirees

• Why meaningful reform may not happen until the last minute

How Social Security Works Today

Social Security is funded primarily through FICA payroll taxes. Workers and employers each pay 6.2% of wages (12.4% total) into the system, which goes toward funding retirement benefits for current retirees.

Here’s the key point: the money doesn’t accumulate in a large “savings account” for future benefits. Instead, today’s payroll taxes go right back out the door to pay today’s beneficiaries. This setup worked well when there were many workers for each retiree, but demographic trends are changing the math.

• Baby Boomers are retiring in large numbers.

• People are living longer, so they collect benefits for more years.

• Birth rates are low, meaning fewer workers are paying into the system.

This imbalance is the root of Social Security’s funding challenge.

What Happens in 2034?

Many people think 2034 is the year Social Security “goes bankrupt.” That’s not the full story.

According to the Social Security Trustees’ report, if Congress does nothing, the system’s trust funds will be depleted by 2034. At that point, incoming payroll taxes would still be enough to pay about 80% of promised benefits.

In practical terms, this would mean an immediate 20% cut in benefits for all recipients. While Social Security wouldn’t disappear, such a cut would have a huge impact on retirees who rely on it as their primary source of income.

Why We Believe Congress Will Act

It’s our opinion that Congress will not allow benefits to be cut so dramatically. Here’s why:

• For a large portion of Americans over age 65, Social Security is the primary source of retirement income.

• Cutting benefits by 20% would potentially impoverish millions of retirees.

• Retirees also represent a powerful voting population, making it politically unlikely that lawmakers would let the system fail without intervention.

That doesn’t mean changes won’t come—but it does make drastic benefit cuts less likely.

Possible Solutions to Fix Social Security

The challenge is real, but there are several practical options available. The earlier these changes are made, the smaller the adjustments need to be. If lawmakers wait until 2034, the fixes may be more drastic. Some of the most common proposals include:

1. Increasing the Taxable Wage Base

Right now, Social Security taxes only apply to wages up to $176,100 (2025 limit). Someone earning $400,000 pays Social Security tax on less than half of their income.

• Raising or eliminating the cap would bring more revenue into the system.

• While no one likes higher taxes, it may be less painful than the economic impact of the sudden cut in Social Security Benefits starting in 2034

2. Extending the Full Retirement Age

Currently, full retirement age is 67. But Social Security hasn’t been properly indexed for life expectancy. Studies suggest that if it were, the full retirement age could be in the early 70s.

• Extending retirement age would reduce how long people collect benefits.

• This adjustment reflects the fact that Americans are living longer and the Social Security system was not originally designed to make payments to retirees for 15+ years

3. Limiting Early Filing Options

Right now, many people file early at 62, locking in a reduced benefit.

• One proposal is to require younger workers (e.g., those 50 and under) to wait until full retirement age to claim.

• This would preserve more assets in the trust over the long term.

Why Reform May Be Delayed

Unfortunately, even though the math is clear, we don’t expect Congress to make many changes before 2034. Why? Because fixing Social Security is a politically unfriendly topic.

• To save the system, lawmakers must either raise taxes or cut benefits.

• Neither of those options wins votes, which makes reform easy to push off.

This likely means the situation will get more tense as we approach 2034. If reforms aren’t passed in time, one possibility is a government bailout of the Social Security Trust, with additional money created to keep it solvent. While this could buy time, it doesn’t address the underlying funding imbalance—and could carry broader economic consequences.

How We Plan Around Social Security Uncertainty

For our clients, we don’t take a “wait and see” approach. Since we don’t know the exact fate of Social Security, for clients under a specific age, we build retirement plans that assume a reduction in benefits.

• If Social Security benefits are reduced in the future, our clients’ plans are already designed to account for the cut, meaning their retirement income won’t be derailed.

• If, on the other hand, Congress keeps Social Security fully intact, that’s fantastic—it simply means more income than we initially projected.

This conservative approach provides peace of mind and ensures that retirement strategies remain flexible no matter what happens in Washington.

The Bottom Line

Social Security faces real funding challenges, but it’s highly unlikely to disappear. Instead, it will probably undergo adjustments to ensure long-term solvency.

For retirees and pre-retirees, the key takeaway is this: don’t panic, but don’t ignore it either. Build your retirement plan with the assumption that Social Security may look different in the future. A fee-based financial planner can help you model different scenarios and build a strategy that works no matter how Congress acts.

If you’d like to explore how Social Security fits into your retirement plan, learn more about our financial planning services here.

About Michael……...

Hi, I’m Michael Ruger. I’m the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.