How Does A SEP IRA Work?

 What is a SEP?

SEP stands for “Simplified Employee Pension”.  The SEP IRA is one of the most common employer sponsored retirement plans used by sole proprietors and small businesses.

Special Establishment Deadline

SEP are one of the few retirement plans that can be established after December 31st which make them a powerful tax tool.  For example, it’s March, you are meeting with your accountant and they deliver the bad news that you have a big tax bill that is due.  You can setup the SEP IRA any time to your tax filing date PLUS extension, fund it, and capture the tax deduction.

Easy to Setup & Low Plan Fees

The other advantage of SEP IRA’s is they are easy to setup and you do not have a third-party administrator to run the plan, so the costs are a lot lower than a traditional 401(k) plans.  These plans can typically be setup with 24 hours.

Contributions limits

SEP IRA contributions are expressed as a percentage of compensation.  The maximum contribution is either 20% of the owners “net earned income” or 25% of the owners W2 wages.  It all depends on how your business is incorporated.  You have the option to contribution any amount less than the maximum contribution.

100% Employer Funded

SEP IRA plans are 100% employer funded meaning there is no employee deferral piece.  Which makes them expense plans to sponsor for a company that eligible employees because the employer contribution is uniform for all employees.  Meaning if the owner contributes 20% of their compensation to the plan for themselves they must also make a contribution equal to 20% of compensation for each eligible employee.  Typically, once employees begin becoming eligible for the plan, a company will terminate the SEP IRA and replace it with either a Simple IRA or 401(k) plans.

Employee Eligibility Requirements

An employee earns a “year of service” for each calendar year that they earn $500 in compensation.  You can see how easy it is to earn a “year of service” in these types of plans.  This is where a lot of companies make an error because they only look at their “full time employees” as eligible.  The good news for business owners is you can keep employees out of the plan for 3 years and then they become eligible in the 4th year of employment.  For example, I am a sole proprietor and I hire my first employee, if my plan document is written correctly, I can keep that employee out of the SEP IRA for 3 years and then they will not be eligible for the employer contribution until the 4th year of employment.

Read This……..Very Important…..

There is a plan document called a 5305 SEP form that is required to sponsor a SEP IRA plan.  This form can be printed off the IRS website or is sometimes provide by the investment platform for your plan.   Remember, SEP IRA plans are “self-administered” meaning that you as the business owner are responsible for keeping the plan in compliance.  Do cannot always rely on your investment advisor or accountant to help you with your SEP IRA plan. You should have a 5305 SEP for in your employer files for each year you have sponsored the plan.   This form does not get filed with the IRS or DOL but rather is just kept in your employer files in the case of an audit. You are required to give this form to all employees of the company each year.  It’s a way of notifying your employees that the plan exists and it lists the eligibility requirements.

Compliance Issues

The main compliance issues to watch out for with these plan is not having that 5305 SEP Form for each year the plan has been sponsored, not accurately identifying eligible employees, and miscalculating your “net earned income” for the max SEP IRA contribution. 

About Michael……...

Hi, I’m Michael Ruger. I’m the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.

How Do Single(k) Plans Work?

What is a Single(k) Plan?

A Single(k) plan is an employer-sponsored retirement plan for owner-only entities, meaning you have no full-time employees. These owner-only entities get the benefits of having a full-fledged 401(k) plan without the large administrative costs associated with traditional 401(k) plans.

What is the definition of a “full-time” employee?

Oftentimes, a small company will have some part-time staff. It does not matter whether you consider them “part-time”, the definition of full-time employee is defined by the IRS as working 1000 hours in a 12-month period. If you have a “full-time” employee, you would not be eligible to sponsor a Single(k) plan.

Types of Contributions

There are two types of contributions to these plans: Employee deferral contributions and employer profit-sharing contributions. The employee deferral piece works like a 401(k) plan. If you are under the age of 50 you can contribute $24,500 in 2026 in employee deferrals. If you are 50-59 or 64 or older, you get the $8,000 catch-up contribution so you can contribute $32,500 in employee deferrals. Beginning in 2026, if you are age 60-63, instead of the $8,000 catch-up, you can contribute an additional $11,250 for a total of $35,750 in employee deferrals.

The reason why these plans are a little different than other employer-sponsored plans is the employee deferral piece allows you to put 100% of your compensation into these plans up to those dollar thresholds.

In addition to the employee deferrals, you can also contribute 20% of your net earned income in the form of a profit-sharing contribution. For example, if you make $100,000 in net earned income from self-employment and you are age 53, you could contribute $32,500 in employee deferrals and then you could contribute an additional $20,000 in the form of a profit-sharing contribution. Making your total pre-tax contribution $52,500.

Establishment Deadline

The deadline for establishing a Solo(k) plan varies based on how the business is incorporated. If the business is an S-Corp or multi-member partnership, the business owner(s) must have the Solo(k) plan setup by December 31st. If the business is a sole proprietor or single member LLC, the Solo(k) plan can be setup by the tax filing deadline plus extension. 

Loans & Roth Deferrals

Single(k) plans provide all of the benefits to the owner of a full 401(k) plan at a fraction of the cost. You can set up the plan to allow 401(k) loan and Roth deferral contributions.

SEP IRA vs Single(k) Plans

A lot of small business owners find themselves in a position where they are trying to decide between setting up a SEP IRA or a Single(k) plan. One of the big factors, that is often times the deciding factor, is how much the owner intends to contribute to the plan. The SEP IRA limits the business owner to just the 20% of net earned income. Whereas the Single(k) plan allows the 20% of net earned income plus the employee deferral contribution amount. However, if 20% of your net earned income would satisfy your target amount then the SEP IRA may be the right choice.

Advanced Strategy Using A Single(k) Plan

Here is a great tax strategy if you have one spouse that is the primary breadwinner bringing in most of the income and the other has self-employment income for a side business. If the spouse with the self-employment income is over the age of 50 and makes $20,000 in net earned income, they could set up a Single(k) Plan and defer the full $20,000 into their Single(k) plan as employee deferrals. If they had a SEP IRA, the max contribution would have been $4,000.

A huge tax savings for a married couple that is looking to lower their tax liability.

About Rob……...

Hi, I’m Rob Mangold. I’m the Chief Operating Officer at Greenbush Financial Group and a contributor to the Money Smart Board blog. We created the blog to provide strategies that will help our readers personally , professionally, and financially. Our blog is meant to be a resource. If there are questions that you need answered, pleas feel free to join in on the discussion or contact me directly.

The Fiduciary Rule: Exposing Your 401(K) Advisor’s Secrets

It’s here.  On June 9, 2017, the long awaited Fiduciary Rule for 401(k) plans will arrive.  The wirehouse and broker-dealer community within the investment industry has fought this new rule every step of the way.  Why? Because their secrets are about to be exposed.  Fee gouging in these 401(k) plans has spiraled out of control and it has gone on for way too long.  While the Fiduciary Rule was designed to better protect plan participants within these employer sponsored retirement plans, the response from the broker-dealer community, in an effort to protect themselves, may actually drive the fees in 401(k) plans higher than they are now.

If your company sponsors an employer sponsored retirement plan and your investment advisor is a broker with one of the main stream wirehouse or broker dealers then they may be approaching you within the next few months regarding a “platform change” for your 401(k) plan.  Best advice, start asking questions before you sign anything!!  The brokerage community is going to try to gift wrap this change and present this as a value added service to their current 401(k) clients when the reality is this change is being forced onto the brokerage community and they are at great risk at losing their 401(k) clients to independent registered investment advisory firms that have served as co-fiduciaries to their plans along.

The Fiduciary Rule requires all investment advisors that handle 401(k) plans to act in the best interest of their clients.  Up until now may brokers were not held to this standard. As long as they delivered the appropriate disclosure documents to the client, the regulations did not require them to act in their client’s best interest. Crazy right?  Well that’s all about to change and the response of the brokerage community will shock you.

I will preface this article by stating that there have been a variety of responses by the broker-dealer community to this new regulation.  While we cannot reasonably gather information on every broker-dealers response to the Fiduciary Rule, this article will provide information on how many of the brokerage firms are responding to the new legislation given our independent research.

SECRET #1:

Many of the brokerage dealers are restricting what 401(k) platforms their brokers can use.  If the broker currently has 401(k) clients that maintain a plan with a 401(k) platform outside of their new “approved list”, they are forcing them to move the plan to a pre-approved platform or the broker will be required to resign as the advisor to the plan.  Even though your current 401(k) platform may be better than the new proposed platform, the broker may attempt to move your plan so they can keep the plan assets.  How is this remotely in your employee’s best interest? But it’s happening.  We have been told that some of these 401(k) providers end up on the “pre-approve list” because they are willing to share fees with the broker dealer. If you don’t share fees, you don’t make the list.  Really ugly stuff!!

SECRET #2:

Because these wirehouses and broker-dealers know that their brokers are not “experts” in 401(k) plans, many of the brokerage firms are requiring their 401(k) plans to add a third-party fiduciary service which usually results in higher plan fees.  The question to ask is “if you were so concerned about our fiduciary liability why did you wait until now to present this third party fiduciary service?”  They are doing this to protect themselves, not the client.   Also, many of these third party fiduciary services could standardize the investment menu and take the control of the investment menu away from the broker.  Which begs the question, what are you paying the broker for?

SECRET #3:

Some broker-dealers are responding to the Fiduciary Rule by forcing their brokers to move all their 401(k) plans to a “fee based platform” versus a commission based platform.  The plan participants may have paid commissions on investments when they were purchased within their 401(k) account and now could be forced out of those investments and locked into a fee based fee structure after they already paid a commission on their balance.  This situation will be common for 401(k) plans that are comprised primarily of self-directed brokerage accounts.  Make sure you ask the advisor about the impact of the fee structure change and any deferred sales charges that may be imposed due to the platform change.

SECRET #4:

The plan fees are often times buried.  The 401(k) industry has gotten very good at hiding fees.  They talk in percentages and basis points but rarely talk in hard dollars.  One percent does not sound like a lot but if you have a $2 million dollar 401(k) plan that equals $20,000 in fees coming out of the plans assets every year.  Most of the fees are buried in the mutual fund expense ratios and you basically have to be an investment expert to figure out how much you are paying.  This has continued to go on because very rarely do companies write a check for their 401(k) fees. Most plans debit plan assets for their plan fees but the fees are real.

With all of these changes taking place, now is the perfect time to take a good hard look at your company’s employer sponsored retirement plan.  If your current investment advisor approaches you with a recommended “platform change” that is a red flag.  Start asking a lot of questions and it may be a good time to put your plan out to bid to see if you can negotiate a better overall solution for you and your employees.

About Michael……...

Hi, I’m Michael Ruger. I’m the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.

Strategies to Save for Retirement with No Company Retirement Plan

The question, “How much do I need to retire?” has become a concern across generations rather than something that only those approaching retirement focus on.  But what if you, or in the case of married couples, your spouse, are not covered by an employer-sponsored retirement plan?  In this article we are going to cover retirement savings strategies for individuals that may not be covered by an employer-sponsored retirement plan.

Married Filing Jointly - One Spouse Covered by Employer Sponsored Plan and is Not Maxing Out

A common strategy we use for clients when a covered spouse is not maxing out their deferrals is to increase the deferrals in the retirement plan and supplement income with the non-covered spouse’s salary.  The limits for 401(k) deferrals in 2025 is $23,500 for individuals under 50,  $31,000 for individuals 50-59 and 64+ and $34,750 for individuals 60-63.  For example, if I am covered and only contribute $8,000 per year to my account and my spouse is not covered but has additional money to save for retirement, I could increase my deferrals up to the plan limits using the amount of additional money we have to save.  This strategy is helpful as it allows for easier tracking of retirement accounts and the money is automatically deducted from payroll.  Also, if you are contributing pre-tax dollars, this will decrease your tax liability.

Note:  Payroll deferrals must be withheld from payroll by 12/31.  If you owe money when you file your taxes in April, you would not be able to go back and increase your deferrals in your company plan for that tax year.

Married Filing Jointly - One Spouse Covered by Employer Sponsored Plan and is Maxing Out

If the covered spouse is maxing out at the high limits already, you may be able to save additional pre-tax dollars depending on your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI).

Below is the Traditional IRA Deductibility Table for 2025.  This table shows how much individuals or married couples can earn and still deduct IRA contributions from their taxable income.

As shown in the chart, if you are married filing jointly and one spouse is covered, the couple can fully deduct IRA contributions to an account in the covered spouses name if AGI is less than $126,000 and can fully deduct IRA contributions to an account in the non-covered spouses name if AGI is less than $236,000.  The Traditional IRA limits for 2025 are $7,000 if under 50 and $8,000 if 50+.  These lower limits and income thresholds make contributing to company sponsor plans more attractive in most cases.

Single or Married Filing Jointly and Neither Spouse is Covered

If you (and your spouse if married filing joint) are not covered by an employer sponsored plan, you do not have an income threshold for contributing pre-tax dollars to a Traditional IRA.  The only limitations you have relate to the amount you can contribute.  These contribution limits for both Traditional and Roth IRA’s are $7,000 if under 50 and $8,000 if 50+.  If married filing joint, each spouse can contribute up to these limits.

Unlike employer sponsored plans, your contributions to IRA’s can be made after 12/31 of that tax year as long as the contributions are in before you file your tax return.

About Rob……...

Hi, I’m Rob Mangold. I’m the Chief Operating Officer at Greenbush Financial Group and a contributor to the Money Smart Board blog. We created the blog to provide strategies that will help our readers personally , professionally, and financially. Our blog is meant to be a resource. If there are questions that you need answered, pleas feel free to join in on the discussion or contact me directly.

A New Year: Should I Make Changes To My Retirement Account?

A simple and easy answer to this question would be…..Maybe?  Not only would that answer make this article extremely short, it wouldn’t explain some important items that participants should take into consideration when making decisions about their retirement plan.Every time the calendar adds a year we get a sense of reset.  A lot of the same tasks on the to do list get added each January and hopefully this article helps you focus on matters to consider regarding your retirement plan.

Should I Consult With The Advisor On My Plan?

At our firm we make an effort to meet with participants at least annually.  Saving in company retirement plans is about longevity so many times the individual meetings are brief and no allocation changes are made.  Even if this is the result, an overview of your account, at least annually, is a good way to keep retirement savings fresh in your mind and add a sense of comfort that you’re investing appropriately based on your time horizon and risk tolerance.

These individual meetings are also a good time to discuss other financial questions you may have.  Your retirement plan is only a piece of your financial plan and we encourage participants to use the resources available to them.  Often times these meetings start off as a simple account overview but turn into lengthy conversations about various financial decisions the participant has been weighing.

How Much Should I Be Contributing This Year?

This answer is not the same for everyone because, among other things, people have different retirement goals, financial situations, and time horizon.  That being said, if the  company has a match component in their plan, the first milestone would be to contribute enough to receive the most the company is willing to give you.  For example, if the company will match 100% of your contributions up to 3% of pay, any amount you contribute less than 3% will leave you missing out on retirement savings the company is willing to provide you.

Again, the amount that should be saved is dependent on the individual but saving anywhere from 10% to 15% of your compensation is a good benchmark.  In the previous example, if the company will match 3%, that means you would have to contribute 7% to achieve the lower end of that benchmark.  This may seem like a difficult task so starting at an amount you are comfortable with and working your way to your ultimate goal is important.

Should You Be Making Allocation Changes?

The initial allocation you choose for your retirement account is important.  Selecting the   appropriate portfolio from the start based on your risk tolerance and time until retirement can satisfy your investment needs for a number of years.  The chart below shows that over longer periods of time historical annual returns tend to be less volatile.

When you have over 10 years until retirement, reviewing the account at least annually is   important as there are a number of reasons you would want to change your allocation.  Lifestyle changes, different retirement goals, or specific investment performance to name a few. Participants tend to lose out on investment return when they try to time the market and are forced to sell low and buy high.  This chart shows that even though there may be volatility in the short term, as long as you have time and an appropriate allocation from the start, you should see returns that will help you achieve your retirement goals. 

About Rob……...

Hi, I’m Rob Mangold. I’m the Chief Operating Officer at Greenbush Financial Group and a contributor to the Money Smart Board blog. We created the blog to provide strategies that will help our readers personally , professionally, and financially. Our blog is meant to be a resource. If there are questions that you need answered, pleas feel free to join in on the discussion or contact me directly.

Simple IRA vs. 401(k) - Which one is right for your company?

compare simple ira and 401k

There are a lot of options available to small companies when establishing an employer sponsored retirement plan. For companies that have employees in addition to the owners of the company, the question is do they establish a 401(k) plan or a Simple IRA?The right fit for your company depends on:

• What are the company's primary goals for establishing the plan?

• How much the owner(s) plan to contribute to the plan?

• How many employees does the company have?

• Do you want to restrict the plan to only full time employees?

• The cost of maintaining each plan?

• Does the company intend to make an employer contribution to the plan?

• Diversity of the investment menu

Below is a chart that contains a quick comparison of some of the main features of each type of plan:

simple ira vs 401K comparison chart

For many small companies it often makes sense to start with a Simple IRA plan and then transition to a 401K plan as the company grows or when the owner intends to start accessing the upper deferral limits offered by the 401(k) plan.

Simple IRA's are relatively easy to setup and the administrative fees to maintain these plans are typically lower in comparison to 401(k) plans. Most Simple IRA providers will only charge $10 - $30 to custody the accounts.

By comparison, 401(k) plans are ERISA covered plans which require a TPA Firm (third party administrator) to maintain the plan documents, conduct year end plan testing, and file the 5500 each year. The TPA fees vary based on the provider and the number of employees eligible to participate in the plan. A ballpark range is $1,500 - $2,500 for companies with under 50 employees.

However, the additional TPA fees associated with establishing a 401(k) plan may be justified if:

• The owners intend to max out their employee deferrals

• The owners are approaching retirement and need to make big contributions

• The company wants to maintain flexibility with the employer contribution

• The company would like to make Roth contributions, loans, or rollovers available

WARNING: Most investment providers are "one trick ponies". They will talk about 401(k) plans and not present other options because they either do not have a thorough understand of how Simple IRA plans work or they are only able to offer 401(k) plans. Before establishing a retirement plan it is important to work with a firm that presents both options, helps you to understand the difference between the two types of plans, and assist you in evaluating which plan would best meet your company's goals and objectives.

Michael Ruger

About Michael.........

Hi, I'm Michael Ruger. I'm the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.

Comparing Different Types of Employer Sponsored Retirement Plans

comparison of different types of retirement plans

Employer sponsored retirement plans are typically the single most valuable tool for business owner when attempting to:

• Reduce their current tax liability

• Attract and retain employees

• Accumulate wealth for retirement

But with all of the different types of plans to choose from which one is the right one for your business?   Most business owners are familiar with how 401(k) plans work but that might not be the right fit given variables such as:

• # of Employees

• Cash flows of the business

• Goals of the business owner

There are four main stream employer sponsored retirement plans that business owners have to choose from:

• SEP IRA

• Single(k) Plan

• Simple IRA

• 401(k) Plan

Since there are a lot of differences between these four types of plans we have included a comparison chart at the conclusion of this newsletter but we will touch on the highlights of each type of plan.

SEP IRA PLAN

This is the only employer sponsored retirement plan that can be setup after 12/31 for the previous tax year.   So when you are sitting with your accountant in the spring and they deliver the bad news that you are going to have a big tax liability for the previous tax year, you can establish a SEP IRA up until your tax filing deadline plus extension, fund it, and take a deduction for that year.

However, if the company has employees that meet the plan’s eligibility requirement, these plans become very expensive very quickly if the owner(s) want to make contributions to their own accounts.  The reason being, these plans are 100% employer funded which means there are no employee contributions allowed and the employer contribution is uniform for all plan participants.  For example, if the owner contributes 15% of their income to the SEP IRA, they have to make an employer contribution equal to 15% of compensation for each employee that has met the plans eligibility requirement.  If the 5305-SEP Form, which serves as the plan document, is setup correctly a company can keep new employees out of the plan for up to 3 years but often times it is either not setup correctly or the employer cannot find the document.

Single(k) Plan or “Solo(k)”

These plans are for owner only entities.  As soon as you have an employee that works more than 1000 hours in a 12 month period, you cannot sponsor a Single(k) plan.

The plans are often times the most advantageous for self-employed individuals that have no employees and want to have access to higher pre-tax contribution levels.  For all intensive purposes it is a 401(k) plan, same contributions limits, ERISA protected, they allow loans and Roth contributions, etc.  However, they can be sponsored at a much lower cost than traditional 401(k) plans because there are no non-owner employees.  So there is no year-end testing, it’s typically a boiler plate plan document, and the administration costs to establish and maintain these plans are typically under $400 per year compared to traditional 401(k) plans which may cost $1,500+ per year to administer.

The beauty of these plans is the “employee contribution” of the plan which gives it an advantage over SEP IRA plans.  With SEP IRA plans you are limited to contributes up to 25% of your income. So if you make $24,000 in self-employment income you are limited to a $6,000 pre-tax contribution.

With a Single(k) plan, for 2016, I can contribute $18,000 per year (another $6,000 if I’m over 50) up to 100% of my self-employment income and in addition to that amount I can make an employer contribution up to 25% of my income.  In the previous example, if you make $24,000 in self-employment income, you would be able to make a salary deferral contribution of $18,000 and an employer contribution of $6,000, effectively wiping out all of your taxable income for that tax year.

Simple IRA

Simple IRA’s are the JV version of 401(k) plans.  Smaller companies that have 1 – 30 employees that are looking to start a retirement plan will often times start with implementing a Simple IRA plan and eventually graduate to a 401(k) plan as the company grows.  The primary advantage of Simple IRA Plans over 401(k) Plans is the cost. Simple IRA’s do not require a TPA firm since they are self-administered by the employer and they do not require annual 5500 filings so the cost to setup and maintain the plan is usually much less than a 401(k) plan.

What causes companies to choose a 401(k) plan over a Simple IRA plan?

• Owners want access to higher pre-tax contribution limits

• They want to limit to the plan to just full time employees

• The company wants flexibility with regard to the employer contribution

• The company wants a vesting schedule tied to the employer contributions

• The company wants to expand the investment menu beyond just a single fund family

401(k) Plans

These are probably the most well recognized employer sponsored plans since at one time or another each of us has worked for a company that has sponsored this type of plan.  So we will not spend a lot of time going over the ins and outs of these types of plan.   These plans offer a lot of flexibility with regard to the plan features and the plan design.

We will issue a special note about the 401(k) market.  For small business with 1 -50 employees, you have a lot of options regarding which type of plan you should sponsor but it’s our personal experience that most investment advisors only have a strong understanding of 401(k) plans so they push 401(k) plans as the answer for everyone because it’s what they know and it’s what they are comfortable talking about.   When establishing a retirement plan for your company, make sure you consult with an advisor that has a working knowledge of all these different types of retirement plans and can clearly articulate the pros and cons of each type of plan. This will assist you in establishing the right type of plan for your company. 

Michael Ruger

About Michael……...

Hi, I’m Michael Ruger. I’m the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.

Target Date Mutual Funds and Their Role in the 401(k) Space

target date mutual funds

In recent years, a growing trend in the 401(k) space has been the use of target date mutual funds.

Target Date Mutual Funds

A target date mutual fund is a fund in the hybrid category that automatically resets the asset mix of stocks, bonds and cash equivalents in its portfolio according to a selected time frame that is appropriate for a particular investor. In simpler terms, an investor can purchase a target date fund based on their anticipated retirement date and the fund will automatically become more conservative as the investor approaches retirement.

This is often times a suitable investment for the average investor or participant in a 401(k) plan that would not typically make allocation adjustments on their own. During the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009, many investors approaching retirement were overexposed to the stock market and lost half of their savings with no time to make it back before retirement. This is where the benefit of a well-managed target date fund would have been useful as investors who needed an allocation change as they approached retirement would have got it. Emphasis on the well-managed.

At year end 2013, there was approximately $595.5 billion dollars invested in target date mutual funds, up from approximately $111.9 billion in 2006 based on a study conducted by Morningstar. With so much money being placed in these funds, it is important to know how they work and what to look for when choosing the correct fund for your risk tolerance and time horizon.

As mentioned previously, the allocation of assets within a target date fund will automatically rebalance throughout the life of the investment to focus more on income. With that being said, how does the rebalancing happen and how often does the rebalancing take place? The rebalancing takes place automatically when fund managers of that target date fund determine the allocation in the fund no longer meets its intentions. It is argued that most target date mutual funds do not rebalance nearly enough as some can be as long as 4-5 years.

It is important to know that the date of a target date fund is the date the investor plans to retire and is not the date in which the fund is at its most conservative allocation. Fund families operate their target date mutual funds very differently. For example, one fund family may have a 2020 fund that is 30% stocks and 70% bonds compared to another more aggressive fund family that is allocated 60% stocks and 40% bonds in their 2020 target date fund.

There are arguments for both allocations. Since an investor is at their retirement age, they should typically be more conservative. On the other hand, just because the investor hit their retirement age they may not be taking distributions from the account for another 5-10 years, and therefore could possibly achieve more growth.

A target date fund can be a suitable investment option for investors who would like a hands off approach in their 401(k), but participants must be aware that there is still due diligence necessary throughout the life of the investment. Below is a chart showing the results of a study conducted by Morningstar in 2010. It shows the allocation of target date mutual funds for different fund families during the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009. These target date mutual funds were meant for investors retiring in 2010 and therefore should have been allocated in a way that would not over expose them to a significant decline in the market two years from retirement.

comparing target date fund performance

As you can see, the equity (stock) allocation varies greatly between fund families and the over exposure led to significant declines in investors accounts. Too many people had their retirement account nearly halved two years from retirement which is devastating for an individuals quality of life.

There are definitely pitfalls to target date mutual funds but they can be appropriate in the right circumstances. It is important that investors are educated on what target date mutual funds are and more importantly what they are not. Here are a few takeaways that may help you determine which, if any, target date fund is appropriate for you.

Determine Your Risk Tolerance First

The first questions an investment advisor will typically have for a client are: “What is your time horizon?” and “What is your risk tolerance?”. Since target date mutual funds allocate assets for a group of investors based on a date in the future, the only piece that is somewhat satisfied is time horizon. Just because a group of investors have the same time horizon does not mean they should be invested the same way. Fund managers cannot allocate funds in a way that satisfies both questions without knowing the risk tolerance for each individual investor. That means, the risk tolerance piece relies on you. Two 45 year old investors may be 20 years from retirement and have completely different portfolio allocations due to their risk tolerance. One may be more aggressive and tolerant of stock market fluctuations while the other may be conservative and less willing to risk their savings. Even though each investor has the same time horizon, the appropriate portfolio for each would vary greatly. It is important to know your risk tolerance and apply that knowledge to the appropriate target date fund.

Research the Different Target Date Fund Options

As shown in the chart on the previous page, the asset allocation for a target date fund for one fund family could be drastically different when compared to the same target date fund for another fund family. This can be confusing for investors which is why it is important to research the fund and the current allocation before investing. The charts below show the asset allocation of two 2020 target date mutual funds from different families.

401K target date funds

Both target date mutual funds are the same in terms of retirement date but drastically different in exposure to the stock market. The MFS 2020 fund with approximately 63% allocated to bonds/cash and 37% to stocks is a much more conservative portfolio than the Fidelity 2020, which is approximately 37% bonds/cash and 63% stocks. An investor with 5 years to retirement could have very different objectives with their retirement account and therefore each fund may be appropriate as a 2020 fund. An over exposure to the stock market for someone retiring in 5 years could be devastating as shown in 2008/2009 which is why it is important for each individual to determine their time horizon, risk tolerance, and investment objectives when selecting the correct target date fund for their portfolio.

Difference Between Target Date and Active Management

Although target date mutual funds are often referred to as “set it and forget it”, there are a number of factors that must be taken into consideration. Most target date mutual funds are typically managed exclusively on time horizon. Fund managers traditionally do not make significant allocation adjustments to these types of funds based on changing market conditions which can leave investors exposed to big drops in the stock market as they approach retirement. Investors within 10 years to retirement should work closely with their investment advisor to make sure they have the right mix of stocks and bonds in their portfolio. 

About Rob……...

Hi, I’m Rob Mangold. I’m the Chief Operating Officer at Greenbush Financial Group and a contributor to the Money Smart Board blog. We created the blog to provide strategies that will help our readers personally , professionally, and financially. Our blog is meant to be a resource. If there are questions that you need answered, pleas feel free to join in on the discussion or contact me directly.